search site:    
 
we'd like to customize your content,

How Skinny is Too Skinny?

Over the weekend I was asked by OK Magazine to comment on the Miss. Universe Australia finalist Stephanie Naumoska. Her extremely thin physique has started a stir of controversy over the need for stricter regulations in beauty pageant application criteria. Although the contestant reports eating multiple times a day and denies having an eating disorder, with a BMI of just 15.1 malnutrition is a major concern.

In the past couple years, after several anorexia related deaths occurred in models the Spanish and Italy Associations of Fashion Designers have banned models with body mass indexes less than 18. And now the Australian Medical Association is encouraging the Miss Universe Pageant to enforce a similar rule for a minimum BMI= 20 for contestants.

There is concern not only for the health of the contestants themselves, but for the young girls that look up to them. Especially for girls that already suffer a poor body image, having such a role model may increase their likelihood of developing an eating disorder.

Comments
Having seen pictures of Stephanie Naumoska, I am really beginning to question the nature of the beast here. I thought we in the U.S. were bad enough, with the anorexia and bulemic purging being such a common challenge of parents with teenage girls (and boys!), but to see someone in this state of malnourishment making it the finals no less! I've had my experience in a few anorexic cases, mostly men actually, suffering from an "atlas complex" as I like to call it: they work out too much, eat too little, and expect their bodies to simply withstand the weight of it all.

Wondering when the tide will turn back, you know?
# Posted By Bill Mitchem, DPT | 5/2/09 11:38 AM
Have to agree that I thought things were bad enough in the States without considering the rest of the world had similar "walking dead" issues! I would call her health into question if she were a woman on the street, but honestly in a competition about feminine beauty and she becomes a runner-up?!
# Posted By Melanie DeLeong, OTR/L | 5/3/09 7:48 PM
It is what I want to find out, thanks.
# Posted By EtherSaga Gold | 7/6/09 2:37 AM
Good site.
# Posted By eve isk | 7/9/09 5:12 AM
 
Copyright © 2010, Valley Forge Publishing Group
2570 Boulevard of the Generals, Ste 220, Norristown, PA 19403
p. 800-983-7737 | f. 610-854-3780 | e. info@therapytimes.com
 
Web Award   APEX Award   ASBPE Award   ASHPE Award